Jury
Prototyping with Fab
It's not yet time to evaluate two other groups, come back on ! You'll get all the instructions on this page 🙂
For this last phase, your project is going to face its final evaluation!
A jury, composed of n groups and 1 tutor who have never seen your project, is going to grade your project on several criteria, and you and your group will evaluate the work of others.
The jury will discover your project through its documentation, so it must be understandable without your input.
Jury's grade will be divided this way:
- Professional Evaluation: 50%
- Peer Evaluation: 50%
Peer Evaluation
You and your group will evaluate the final project of n groups, and yours will be evaluated by n groups as well.
Your group will have to evaluate projects on the following criteria:
Demonstration /5
- The problematic is clearly defined
- The context and target are clear
- The usage scenario is clear
- The solution is relevant
- The video demonstrates the use of the prototype
Design process /5
- The evolution of the prototype is clearly shown
- Technical and design choices are relevant
- Problems encountered are explained as well as their resolution.
- Improvements take into account users feedback
- Directions for the continuation of the project are given
Prototyping techniques /5
- Use of rapid prototyping technologies
- Quality of fabrication of the prototype
- The quick and dirty design is relevant regarding to ideal prototype
- 3D Design and/or 2D Design files are provided
- The integration of figma application and/or electronics is relevant
Documentation /5
- Information structure follows the provided template
- The video explains the evolution of the project
- Overall quality of documentation
- Illustrations are relevant and appealing
- Bills of materials are well detailed and clear
And your project will be evaluated on the same criteria.
This is a team activity! You have to schedule a meeting with all your team members to evaluate other groups works (without a tutor and without the other groups).
The peer evaluation can be done correctly in less than an hour without rushing. Groups that do not complete their peer evaluation on time will be sanctioned.
You have until to complete your evaluations.
Congratulations! You've reached the end of this course 👏👏👏
You've come a long way and have learned a lot depsite the difficulties, you can be proud of yourselves and what you've accomplished!
